Natsu Dragneel Vs. Erza Scarlet

[Makoto Cifer]

Location: An ancient battleground
Distance:10ft
Weather: Sunny
Time of day: Noon
Restrctions: Erza cannot requip flame empress armor

I love both Natsu and Erza, however I believe that Natsu is a failure as a main protagonist. He has zero character development and is pretty much a punching throughout the series. Who wins?

[Ohako]

I came to this thread saying that she would win with Flame empress armor. Hmmm I still see Erza winning this with Heavens Wheel Armor. I don't see Natsu surviving that. Erza also has the ability to use water with the Sea Empress water. That could handle Natsu's fire, but still she would use Heaven's Wheel before that.

[Makoto Cifer]

Originally Posted by Ohako

I came to this thread saying that she would win with Flame empress armor. Hmmm I still see Erza winning this with Heavens Wheel Armor. I don't see Natsu surviving that. Erza also has the ability to use water with the Sea Empress water. That could handle Natsu's fire, but still she would use Heaven's Wheel before that.

I'm comparing Natsu's feats and Erza's feats. Even unequiped, she still displays decent speed and mobility, not to mention her swordsmanship. However, if she utilizes an armor that has an element, such as Thunder empress armor, then Natsu could eat that element and become enhanced for short period. That said, Natsu and Erza display equivalent speed, but Natsu surpasses Erza in strenght, depending on the armor.

[Ohako]

Originally Posted by Makoto Cifer

I'm comparing Natsu's feats and Erza's feats. Even unequiped, she still displays decent speed and mobility, not to mention her swordsmanship. However, if she utilize an armor that has an element, such as Thunder empress armor, then Natsu could eat that element and become enhanced for short period. That said, Natsu and Erza display equivalent speed, but Natsu surpasses Erza in strenght, depending on the armor.

Natsu has way more Stamina and determination by all he has been through. Then Erza though Erza's personality is the same and her other feats are better then Natsu. Speed, power, defense. Her Armor can make up almost for any feats she lacks in or wants to improve. I also doubt she would risk using elements like lighting she knows Natsu very well. She even saw his fire lighting dragon magic up close no way would she let him do that.

[Makoto Cifer]

Originally Posted by Ohako

Natsu has way more Stamina and determination by all he has been through. Then Erza though Erza's personality is the same and her other feats are better then Natsu. Speed, power, defense. Her Armor can make up almost for any feats she lacks in or wants to improve. I also doubt she would risk using elements like lighting she knows Natsu very well. She even saw his fire lighting dragon magic up close no way would she let him do that.

I agree.

[Noctis Arashi]

Erza has far more stamina than Natsu. She took on all 100 monsters, more than one of which were stronger than the a member of the 10 wizard saints.

And she won.

Natsu hasn't shown anything on that scale, ever. With the knowledge that she has on Natsu already, she pretty handily takes this.

[Uchiha Sora]

Natsu's "stamina" comes from "Lulz i must s4ve my nakamaassss!!!11"

Erza has legit stamina. Takin on 100 monsters, a handful being S rank

[Vivi]

You should also note that she took on the 100 Monsters with the Armour that has its entire focus on Offense and nothing else.

Her stamina,defense and speed aren't augmented at all.

[BMC1994]

This is quite off topic but how awesome is fairy tail.

Better then bleach fight-wise or not?

[Uchiha Sora]

Watch the first episode and make your decision

That was a pretty good fight, even though there are many many better ones in Ft

[Ohako]

Originally Posted by Noctis Arashi

Erza has far more stamina than Natsu. She took on all 100 monsters, more than one of which were stronger than the a member of the 10 wizard saints.

And she won.

Natsu hasn't shown anything on that scale, ever. With the knowledge that she has on Natsu already, she pretty handily takes this.

Hmm yes yes. Idk why i forgot and i was thinking about that moment my bad, but in all i was on Erza's side to begin with.

Originally Posted by BMC1994

This is quite off topic but how awesome is fairy tail.

Better then bleach fight-wise or not?

I prefer Fairy Tail more then Bleach. Some bleach fights are really good, but there are some good fights. Usually not with the main character though

[Devils Lawyer]

This would lean more in the tie category. But Natsu strongest forms is clearly more powerful than Erza. He always defeated the enemy that was a few steps more powerful than her opponent.

[321zigzag3]

In theory Dragonforce Natsu + lightning should defeat Erza.

But we have not seen Natsu manually access the form.

[shinigan no sora]

Erza equips lust armor. Fight turns into a doujinshi or lemon fanfic

Either way kinda hard to tell who wins that one.

But in all seriousness erza probably outlasts natsu and then she kicks his face into the dirt

Wait that sounds like how a doujinshi might end too damn

[321zigzag3]

LFD Dragonforce Natsu >>> Erza.

[Ohako]

Yeah agreed lighting dragon Natsu i say is stronger then Erza. I picked Erza to win, because he can't really control well/go in that mode at will. He seems shaky on it.