Are some of Sasuke's actions justified?

[WishfulFairie]

Originally Posted by PrinceofPeace

I know I am sound like a broken record but IMO all of his actions are justified ...EXCEPT you know what! I mean I am answering the question and nobdoy has proved me wrong

We all know you were right. Don't drag this.

[PrinceofPeace]

But someone asked me a question!?!? Whatever I am done I made my point

[kaci]

Okay, I can see from Sasuke's point of view about killing Danzo,

But not wiping out/hating the leaf. That part I don't think is right at all.

Its like, did Shino have any part in the killing of his clan? Uhm, no.
Did Hinata? No..
Did Iruka? Um, no, not really..
Sakura? Pshh, she had no idea what was going on.
Ino? Nopeee.
And many more.

The Leaf is full of people who were on his side since the beginning, that cared, praised, and adored him as Sasuke Uchiha. Why can't he get his dumb revenge on people that acutally had a part in the killing of his clan? Not others, who are completely innocent and make great characters?
That's just what I think. Personally.

[Shisko Shi]

Originally Posted by kaci

Okay, I can see from Sasuke's point of view about killing Danzo,

But not wiping out/hating the leaf. That part I don't think is right at all.

Its like, did Shino have any part in the killing of his clan? Uhm, no.
Did Hinata? No..
Did Iruka? Um, no, not really..
Sakura? Pshh, she had no idea what was going on.
Ino? Nopeee.
And many more.

The Leaf is full of people who were on his side since the beginning, that cared, praised, and adored him as Sasuke Uchiha. Why can't he get his dumb revenge on people that acutally had a part in the killing of his clan? Not others, who are completely innocent and make great characters?
That's just what I think. Personally.

Shino, Hinata, Iruka, Ino, and Sakura lost theirs too?? oO

[kaci]

Originally Posted by Shisko Shi

Shino, Hinata, Iruka, Ino, and Sakura lost theirs too?? oO

Lost their what? Hahhaa.

[PrinceofPeace]

Originally Posted by kaci

Okay, I can see from Sasuke's point of view about killing Danzo,

But not wiping out/hating the leaf. That part I don't think is right at all.

Its like, did Shino have any part in the killing of his clan? Uhm, no.
Did Hinata? No..
Did Iruka? Um, no, not really..
Sakura? Pshh, she had no idea what was going on.
Ino? Nopeee.
And many more.

The Leaf is full of people who were on his side since the beginning, that cared, praised, and adored him as Sasuke Uchiha. Why can't he get his dumb revenge on people that acutally had a part in the killing of his clan? Not others, who are completely innocent and make great characters?
That's just what I think. Personally.

Another great original reasonlll great job newbie

[The Sanninkage]

Originally Posted by kaci

Okay, I can see from Sasuke's point of view about killing Danzo,

But not wiping out/hating the leaf. That part I don't think is right at all.

Its like, did Shino have any part in the killing of his clan? Uhm, no.
Did Hinata? No..
Did Iruka? Um, no, not really..
Sakura? Pshh, she had no idea what was going on.
Ino? Nopeee.
And many more.

The Leaf is full of people who were on his side since the beginning, that cared, praised, and adored him as Sasuke Uchiha. Why can't he get his dumb revenge on people that acutally had a part in the killing of his clan? Not others, who are completely innocent and make great characters?
That's just what I think. Personally.

I get what your saying but do you think anyone would allow Sasuke to skip happily into the village and just slaughter the elders without doing anything about it. In fact, they would probably all go after Sasuke either way. Its like when PrinceofPeace mentioned the death of the samurai. I doubt they were going to just let Sasuke walk right in and stab Danzo to death. Thus the logical reaction would be to K.O./kill anyone in the way.

[PrinceofPeace]

Yes the samurai were doing their job and would not let Saskue walk freely
BUT YOU FORGET !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Saskue took out an army of oto ninja WITHOUT killing them so how is that different from k.o some fodder samurai??? Saskue was more powerful since the time he took out the oto ninja so he could have k.o. some samurai

They did not NEED to die. Saskue's goal was the elders NOT anyone else

[WishfulFairie]

yes yes the samurai's death was not justified
that was established


prince will go on for days if you don't agree with him

[PrinceofPeace]

sorry he called me out . I was just complimenting someone else minding my own bussiness then WHAM someone calls out my name SO IT"S ON

[The Sanninkage]

Originally Posted by PrinceofPeace

sorry he called me out . I was just complimenting someone else minding my own bussiness then WHAM someone calls out my name SO IT"S ON

I wasn't calling you out, i was using what you stated earlier as a reference for my point in what someone just pointed out. Don't be an Ino. lol

[PrinceofPeace]

how am I being..... FORGET it! lol

Saskue's actions are NOT justified and thats that
-Killed innocent Samarui
-hated the ENTIRE leaf village for the Uchiha's demise when most had nothing to do with it

[Desert Sage]

I believe that Sasuke believes that his actions are justified. But Sasuke acts very selfishly and self-righteously. Everyone believes, or at least thinks, that what they are doing is right. that is the human condition, in Narutos world, as in Sasukes, as in our own. Sasuke has seen and experienced extreme injustice. Has no one here ever taken matters into their own hands, regardless of the norms and others thoughts or beliefs in pursuit of the justice that will never be seen and has quietly drifted into the shadows? Not saying Sasukes actions are right, but not saying that I wouldnt be inclined to make similar decisions if I were to have to walk his path. A concept that only adds depth and complexity to the pursuit of "one day seeing a world where people can live in mutual understanding of each others feelings". Naruto fights for it, Nagato fought for it as does Sasuke. But both Naruto and Nagato came to an epiphany...that maybe the way they were trying to achieve this end was not in fact what was the right or best way to do it. Sasuke has not had that realization yet it seems. Additionally, Sasukes anger makes him an easy tool or pawn to be manipulated. So all-in-all I say Sasukes actions are justified, however lacking in depth of thought, consideration of the ninja way and moral fiber.

[Desert Sage]

Originally Posted by PrinceofPeace

^ Where did you get that??

The Samurai were just doing their job. Saskue never killed people until that moment. This is the only thing that Saskue did that can not be justified. I still think he should be let back into the Leaf and he is not as bad as when garra was evil but this is not right

The Samurai were innocent no doubt, but considering the marginally decent level of historical accuracy that Narutos world has infused into it, then we have to accept that the ninja were in fact originally created as militia that were trained to be anti-samurai specialists during the "warring states period" of Japan, something that is historically embodied in the description of the great ninja wars. Many innocents exist on both sides, but either way, Samurai and Ninja, unless contracted together often were to kill each other on sight. The action though, yes, I agree, was NOT justified.

[PrinceofPeace]

THANK YOU!!!

Just oh my gosh ... I can not Rest In Piece

[The Sanninkage]

Originally Posted by PrinceofPeace

THANK YOU!!!

Just oh my gosh ... I can not Rest In Piece

@PrinceofPeace Now you've ruining my topic by making it all your samurai thanks a lot Sakura

[PrinceofPeace]

ummmmmmm... your welcome ????

[Ariana Dean]

Nothing about him is justified except killing Danzo.

[joon61]

I agree with you there.

[Saiyan]

No```