byakugan vs sharingan

[Uchiha Sora]

Originally Posted by megabbaut

Chidori isn't a bloodline trait either, but Naruto couldn't learn it.

Byakugan chakra control surpasses even Jonin level.

Gentle Fist is a Byakugan tech, so all of it's variants are grants. Including Kaiten since Susanoo is included and that doesn't come from the eyes

Thats because he doesn't have the right chakra nature. Any other lightning-chakra person could learn it.

Point being?

No, anybody can use gentle fist, they just won't know where the chakra points are. Are you trying to tell me that you have to be a hyuuga to emit chakra at the tips of your fingers and poke? No. Byakugan just makes everything easier.

Of course Susano'o comes from the eyes. Its a Mangekyo Technique. Unlike any of the Hyuuga's techniques, which are just emitting chakra in various parts of the body, which anyone can do. Sure the Hyuuga are on a different level, but you can train to get to that level.

Byakugan's sole abilities are to see Chakra,Chakra networks, and roughly 360 degree vision. It has no other techniques. It only allows for easier execution of other various techniques

Gentle fist was a "created" fighting style,meant to be used along with the byakugan. Techniques like Susano'o actually comes from the eye itself.

EDDIT:damn i'm getting sucked back into this stuff =_=

[321zigzag3]

How did this reach 7 pages?

Put yourself in Kishimoto's shoes in how he treated his manga and also look at his face.

Spoiler:

There is your answer regardless of your personal preference for either the Sharingan or Byakugan.

[Uchiha Sora]

Wait wasn't it already proven that Sharingan is overall more useful....?

Originally Posted by Uchiha_Sora

Byakugan:
-Sees Chakra
-Sees Chakra Network
-Almost 360 Degree vision
Sharingan:
-Sees Chakra
-Boosted reaction time/Precognition
-Susano'o
-Amaterasu
-Tsukuyomi
-Other Genjutsu
-Genjutsu Reversal
-User Specific Techniques such as Kamui, Kotoamatsukami
-Eternal MS which allows for perfect vision and possibly no fatigue
-Rinnegan Evolution(Then all of the other various rinnegan techs included)
-Able to Copy other techniques as long as its not Kekkei Genkai

Overall, Sharingan is more useful.

/thread

[megabbaut]

Originally Posted by Uchiha_Sora

Thats because he doesn't have the right chakra nature. Any other lightning-chakra person could learn it.

Point being?

No, anybody can use gentle fist, they just won't know where the chakra points are. Are you trying to tell me that you have to be a hyuuga to emit chakra at the tips of your fingers and poke? No. Byakugan just makes everything easier.

Of course Susano'o comes from the eyes. Its a Mangekyo Technique. Unlike any of the Hyuuga's techniques, which are just emitting chakra in various parts of the body, which anyone can do. Sure the Hyuuga are on a different level, but you can train to get to that level.

Byakugan's sole abilities are to see Chakra,Chakra networks, and roughly 360 degree vision. It has no other techniques. It only allows for easier execution of other various techniques

Gentle fist was a "created" fighting style,meant to be used along with the byakugan. Techniques like Susano'o actually comes from the eye itself.

EDDIT:damn i'm getting sucked back into this stuff =_=

Chidori isn't really lightning, otherwise it'd be Raiton: Chidori. Just like how Airpalm isn't wind

No...not just anyone can learn Gentle Fist. I am quoting Tenten straight from chapter 101 page 7.

''Normally, control of chakra from the chakra openings is difficult...Even a Jounin can only release from from his hand or leg. One part of his body while doing a technique...

But with Neji, who has mastered the Gentle Fist Style, he can release chakra from the entire body, and knock away physical attacks just with that.''

This indicates that it would take a normal person to have greater chakra control than, let's say, Kakashi (who is a Jounin) who even made a stronger version of Chidori that not even Sasuke was able to learn in the timeskip, to be able to learn Gentle Fist.

With the Byakugan's enhanced chakra control, that gives availability to jutsu that require intense chakra control, like Kaiten and Full Body Blow.

Susanoo doesn't come from the eyes. It forms around the user, like Kaiten does. It would make no sense to include Susanoo as a Doujutsu ability, but not Kaiten.

Aw you figured me out XD

EDIT: Also that list excluded a lot of Byakugan's abilities. Like:

X-ray vision
Kaiten
Gentle Fist
Twin Lion Fists
Full Body Blow
Enhanced chakra control
Added resistance to genjutsu


Not to mention that they failed to mention the Sharingan's many drawbacks, such as the side effects of using MS jutsu and the risky requirements to even acquire and evolve the Sharingan, while Byakugan is given at birth and has no drawbacks as long as it's not kept up for days.

EDIT: And zigzag321, that is not Kishimoto. That looks too much like Miyamoto to me.

[321zigzag3]

Originally Posted by megabbaut

EDIT: And zigzag321, that is not Kishimoto. That looks too much like Miyamoto to me.

[Vivi]

Originally Posted by megabbaut

Chidori isn't really lightning, otherwise it'd be Raiton: Chidori. Just like how Airpalm isn't wind

Raikiri is also just a Raikiri yet it is Lightning.
Chidori is Sasuke's version.
So yes it is Lightning.

''Normally, control of chakra from the chakra openings is difficult...Even a Jounin can only release from from his hand or leg. One part of his body while doing a technique...

But with Neji, who has mastered the Gentle Fist Style, he can release chakra from the entire body, and knock away physical attacks just with that.''

Good.You've proven the Hyuuga are more skilled at releasing Chakra nothing more.

With the Byakugan's enhanced chakra control, that gives availability to jutsu that require intense chakra control, like Kaiten and Full Body Blow.

Baseless.

Susanoo doesn't come from the eyes. It forms around the user, like Kaiten does. It would make no sense to include Susanoo as a Doujutsu ability, but not Kaiten.

How desperate are you?

You know as well as we all do Susanoo comes from the Eyes as it is granted by the MS.
Kaiten isn't.

So stop pulling on straws.

X-ray vision
Kaiten
Gentle Fist
Twin Lion Fists
Full Body Blow
Enhanced chakra control
Added resistance to genjutsu

Kaiten is just Chakra Release which anyone can do and learn.
Gentle Fist is just a Fighting Style thats works in combinaton with the Byakugan.
Twin Lion Fists same as Kaiten just Chakra Release.
Same.
Nope.
Baseless.

[megabbaut]

Good.You've proven the Hyuuga are more skilled at releasing Chakra nothing more.

Also that normal people cannot learn it just by training.

Baseless.

Did you not read the part where it it surpasses Jounin level? Jounins like Kakashi included?

How desperate are you?

You know as well as we all do Susanoo comes from the Eyes as it is granted by the MS.
Kaiten isn't.

So stop pulling on straws.

Susanoo has never shown to come from the eyes like Ammy and Tsukuyomi. It appears all around the user, obviously.
It's basically Kaiten without the rotation.
And as said before, Kaiten has never shown to be wielded by a non-Byakugan user, so it must be assumed that it's a Byakugan ability.
And about your example of Itachi's MS Pre:
He was the only known user of the MS at that time, as Kakashi and Sasuke had yet to learn it, and Shisui and Madara were yet to be explained.
So in PTS Itachi was the only MS user. That's as simple as it gets.

I'm not pulling any straws around here.

Kaiten is just Chakra Release which anyone can do and learn.
Gentle Fist is just a Fighting Style thats works in combinaton with the Byakugan.
Twin Lion Fists same as Kaiten just Chakra Release.
Same.
Nope.
Baseless.

-Already talked about Kaiten
Twin Lion Fists is a Gentle Fist variant, and since Gentle Fist is mainly for the Byakugan, it must be considered part of the Byakugan as well.
Due to chakra control.
Proved by Tenten's words in chapter 101.

About the genjutsu resistance:

Byakugan users are chakra manipulator masters. As we all know, one of the ways to counter genjutsu is to stop your chakra flow temporarily. Because of the chakra abnormalities with genjutsu, They would notice in an instant if they were in a genjutsu and dispel it in this way. They use chakra control in their fighting style. Dispelling a genjutsu would be easy for them.

[UchihaXSasuke]

mega the point is that
nobody can use amaterasu,susanoo,tsukuyomi,kamui,etc... without sharingan,MS,EMS
byakugan doesn't unlocks any ability
that guy in the mist that has byakugan can't use the gentle fist or kaiten
why
because he is not a hyuga(hyuga are the best at releasing chakra and stuff like that)
kaiten can be done without byakugan

[megabbaut]

Originally Posted by UchihaXSasuke

mega the point is that
nobody can use amaterasu,susanoo,tsukuyomi,kamui,etc... without sharingan,MS,EMS
byakugan doesn't unlocks any ability
that guy in the mist that has byakugan can't use the gentle fist or kaiten
why
because he is not a hyuga(hyuga are the best at releasing chakra and stuff like that)
kaiten can be done without byakugan

If you mean Ao then nowhere has it been proved that Ao cannot use Gentle Fist or Kaiten. Otherwise, he wouldn't have survived a battle with Shisui, the man who is stronger than Itachi.
Neither has it been shown that Kaiten can be used by non-Byakugan users. Must I bring up Tenten's talk again? Neji, a Byakugan user, can release chakra from any point in his body while even Jounin can only release chakra from one point in their body. This has been proven by Kakashi, a Jounin, only being able to open one gate. Lee and Guy's fighting style enable the use of gates. The point is, outsiders cannot use Byakugan abilities effectively like Hyugas can. Otherwise Naruto could've been able to do it a long time ago ever since he has been able to do a Rasengan.

[Isoteen]

Originally Posted by megabbaut

If you mean Ao then nowhere has it been proved that Ao cannot use Gentle Fist or Kaiten. Otherwise, he wouldn't have survived a battle with Shisui, the man who is stronger than Itachi.
Neither has it been shown that Kaiten can be used by non-Byakugan users. Must I bring up Tenten's talk again? Neji, a Byakugan user, can release chakra from any point in his body while even Jounin can only release chakra from one point in their body. This has been proven by Kakashi, a Jounin, only being able to open one gate. Lee and Guy's fighting style enable the use of gates. The point is, outsiders cannot use Byakugan abilities effectively like Hyugas can. Otherwise Naruto could've been able to do it a long time ago ever since he has been able to do a Rasengan.

Not exactly true.

Sage Mode allows the user to release chakra from the body as well.

Also, Jinchurikis obviously are able to release chakra everywhere.

Not exactly sure where you're going with this post.

As we all understand small scale chakra release does not compared to a full blown Susano.

[megabbaut]

Originally Posted by Isoteen

Not exactly true.

Sage Mode allows the user to release chakra from the body as well.

Also, Jinchurikis obviously are able to release chakra everywhere.

Not exactly sure where you're going with this post.

As we all understand small scale chakra release does not compared to a full blown Susano.

But does it allow the user to use jutsu such as Kaiten and Full Body Blow? Of course not.

Jinchurikis are able to do that thanks to their chakra cloaks.

And I hope you understand that Kaiten is not small scale. At all.

[Uchiha Sora]

Originally Posted by megabbaut

If you mean Ao then nowhere has it been proved that Ao cannot use Gentle Fist or Kaiten. Otherwise, he wouldn't have survived a battle with Shisui, the man who is stronger than Itachi.
Neither has it been shown that Kaiten can be used by non-Byakugan users. Must I bring up Tenten's talk again? Neji, a Byakugan user, can release chakra from any point in his body while even Jounin can only release chakra from one point in their body. This has been proven by Kakashi, a Jounin, only being able to open one gate. Lee and Guy's fighting style enable the use of gates. The point is, outsiders cannot use Byakugan abilities effectively like Hyugas can. Otherwise Naruto could've been able to do it a long time ago ever since he has been able to do a Rasengan.

i'm gonna post this 1 more time.

None of these techniques come from the eye itself.
they are techniques created to go along with the byakugan.
Techniques such as Tsukuyomi are the eye's literal ability. It was not some side created technique or fighting style, it is an ability granted by the eye itself.

Kaiten,8 Trigrams, Gentle fist, air palm, etc. They are techniques anyone can do with proper training, as I said. There effectiveness however, would be significantly reduced without the posession of a byakugan. And how long that training would take, idk. people like Sasuke can release chakra from all around their body(chidori stream), and then theres A with his Raiton Armor. I bet I could find more if I thought about it longer too.

Originally Posted by Uchiha_Sora

Byakugan:
-Sees Chakra
-Sees Chakra Network
-Almost 360 Degree vision
-Extended Vision

Sharingan:
-Sees Chakra
-Boosted reaction time/Precognition
-Susano'o
-Amaterasu
-Tsukuyomi
-Other Genjutsu
-Genjutsu Reversal
-User Specific Techniques such as Kamui, Kotoamatsukami
-Eternal MS which allows for perfect vision and possibly no fatigue
-Rinnegan Evolution(Then all of the other various rinnegan techs included)
-Able to Copy other techniques as long as its not Kekkei Genkai

Overall, Sharingan is more useful.

/thread

Rinnegan Evolution makes this a complete stomp.

[MinatoXNaruto]

Amaterasu, Genjutsu, Susanoo. Need a say much more. Let's not forget EMS. Imagine having the ability to spam amaterasu without any repercussion. That's unthinkable. Also sharingan can turn into rinnegan. Byakugan has a freaking blindspot. The sharingan is easily better than byakugan.

[Light&Day]

Originally Posted by megabbaut

But does it allow the user to use jutsu such as Kaiten and Full Body Blow? Of course not.

Jinchurikis are able to do that thanks to their chakra cloaks.

And I hope you understand that Kaiten is not small scale. At all.

neji is the best at releasing chakra from all the points of his body
I agree
but byakugan has nothing to do with that
if you say it does than prove it with canon informations

[Vivi]

Originally Posted by Uchiha_Sora

And how long that training would take, idk. people like Sasuke can release chakra from all around their body(chidori stream), and then theres A with his Raiton Armor. I bet I could find more if I thought about it longer too.

Anyone can release Chakra as that is what Nature Transformation basically is.

Hence the names.
Fire Release
Wind Release
Water Release
Earth Release
Lightning Release

among others.



Hyuuga just release Chakra without moulding it into a Nature and even that can be learned.
EG: Chakra Scalpel = no Nature just released Chakra concentrated into the Hands forming Blades.

Even Genjutsu is Chakra Release cause the users Chakra Flow extends into the Enemy nerve system.
Or going after Zangetsu Hozuki:
Yin Release.

So basically:
Hyuuga Chakra Release has nothing to do with Byakugan.

Thus Rotation,Air Palm and everything else neither as it is basic Chakra Release.

[UchihaXSasuke]

Originally Posted by Vivi

Anyone can release Chakra as that is what Nature Transformation basically is.

Hence the names.
Fire Release
Wind Release
Water Release
Earth Release
Lightning Release

among others.



Hyuuga just release Chakra without moulding it into a Nature and even that can be learned.
EG: Chakra Scalpel = no Nature just released Chakra concentrated into the Hands forming Blades.

Even Genjutsu is Chakra Release cause the users Chakra Flow extends into the Enemy nerve system.
Or going after Zangetsu Hozuki:
Yin Release.

So basically:
Hyuuga Chakra Release has nothing to do with Byakugan.

Thus Rotation,Air Palm and everything else neither as it is basic Chakra Release.

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

[megabbaut]

Originally Posted by Uchiha_Sora

i'm gonna post this 1 more time.

None of these techniques come from the eye itself.
they are techniques created to go along with the byakugan.
Techniques such as Tsukuyomi are the eye's literal ability. It was not some side created technique or fighting style, it is an ability granted by the eye itself.

Kaiten,8 Trigrams, Gentle fist, air palm, etc. They are techniques anyone can do with proper training, as I said. There effectiveness however, would be significantly reduced without the posession of a byakugan. And how long that training would take, idk. people like Sasuke can release chakra from all around their body(chidori stream), and then theres A with his Raiton Armor. I bet I could find more if I thought about it longer too.


/thread

Rinnegan Evolution makes this a complete stomp.

A doesn't have Sharingan. Chidori Stream doesn't require the Sharingan. The regular Chidori was actually shown to be able to be used without the Sharingan. It was even created by a non-Shaingan user (Kakashi) before he even acquired the Sharingan. The Sharingan only made it more effective. This isn't the case with abilities such as Kaiten and 8 trigrams. Unlike the Gentle Fist, no one who wasn't a Hyuuga was shown using it. The fact that it involves and requires the Byakugan in order to be even used in the first place shows that it must be considered part of the Byakugan's abilities, because that's what the Byakugan is for. You have to exert chakra from multiple parts of the body in the shape of those techniques, which the manga states that you must surpass Jounin level to even be able to do so. Not even Kakashi can do it, but this isn't the case with the Byakugan. It enables you to have enhanced chakra control, to the point where you can release chakra from your entire body. See Tenten's words about Kaiten and Gentle Fist.

And here's some more evidence if I may add. Chapter 193 page 17.

Now, why do you think they put a close of of Neji's Byakugan in the lower left panel if it had nothing to do with emitting chakra from every chakra opening in his body? Because it does. It wasn't put there for decoration.

Plus, it's not even confirmed that it gives Rinnegan Evolution. It's pure speculation. Because by the logic, the Sharingan also evolves into the Byakugan, as stated by Kakashi.

Anyone can release Chakra as that is what Nature Transformation basically is.

Hence the names.
Fire Release
Wind Release
Water Release
Earth Release
Lightning Release

among others.



Hyuuga just release Chakra without moulding it into a Nature and even that can be learned.
EG: Chakra Scalpel = no Nature just released Chakra concentrated into the Hands forming Blades.

Even Genjutsu is Chakra Release cause the users Chakra Flow extends into the Enemy nerve system.
Or going after Zangetsu Hozuki:
Yin Release.

So basically:
Hyuuga Chakra Release has nothing to do with Byakugan.

Thus Rotation,Air Palm and everything else neither as it is basic Chakra Release.

No one can release chakra at more than one point in their body in the shape of techniques such as Kaiten, air palm, or full body blow.

Most of these Nature Transformations do not do this. They only mold chakra into the given element, then shoot it from a given point in their body, such as shooting fireballs from the mouth.

Even Jounin can only release chakra at one point in their body, and if even they can't do it, then it's impossible without the usage of the Byakugan.

Chakra Scalpel is not a bloodline trait as medical ninja such as Sakura and Tsunade can use it, as well as having a different chakra structure than Gentle Fist. Kabuto cannot exert chakra from multiple openings in his body.

Genjutsu does not come from more than one point in the body.

The point here is that, in order to use Gentle Fist, Kaiten, Full Body Blow, e.t.c. you must exert chakra from multiple parts of the body, not just from your hands or legs. Even Jounin cannot do this, so not just anyone can do it even with proper training.

[Rorin]

Well I'm sorry to tell you that byakugan doesn't stand a chance against sharingan that's why its ranked 2nd best something i don't remember very well help me out with this one.

[Vivi]

Originally Posted by Rorin

Well I'm sorry to tell you that byakugan doesn't stand a chance against sharingan that's why its ranked 2nd best something i don't remember very well help me out with this one.

Basically Rinnegan>Sharingan>Byakugan

No one can release chakra at more than one point in their body in the shape of techniques such as Kaiten, air palm, or full body blow.

Chidori Stream.
Susanoo.
Kagutsuchi

Just a few examples.

And even then doesn't matter.
Still no Byakugan Trait just well developed Chakra control.

Most of these Nature Transformations do not do this. They only mold chakra into the given element, then shoot it from a given point in their body, such as shooting fireballs from the mouth.

Which doesn't change one bit that it's still Chakra Release and further proves my point that anyone can learn it and is not a Byakugan Trait.

Even Jounin can only release chakra at one point in their body,
and if even they can't do it, then it's impossible without the usage of the Byakugan.

Again:
Chidori Stream.
Kagutsuchi.
Twin Rasengan.
Double Raikiri

Just as examples.

Chakra Scalpel is not a bloodline trait as medical ninja such as Sakura and Tsunade can use it, as well as having a different chakra structure than Gentle Fist. Kabuto cannot exert chakra from multiple openings in his body.

Which is irrelevant as obviously my Point was that anyone can release Chakra.
And multiple openings...yeah Kabuto uses it in both hands.

Genjutsu does not come from more than one point in the body.

Cause just Danzo's WHOLE Body was an Illusion right?

The point here is that, in order to use Gentle Fist, Kaiten, Full Body Blow, e.t.c. you must exert chakra from multiple parts of the body, not just from your hands or legs.

Even Jounin cannot do this, so not just anyone can do it even with proper training.

I know and multiple People have done it.

Sasuke.
Naruto.
Guy.
Kakashi.
Danzo.

Matter of fact is:
You still provide no canon source of what you say is true just more stuff that is incredibly vague and disproven multiple times and are still sitting on them doing everything in your Power to prove yourself right.

This Thread is finished anyway.
Sharingan obviously>Byakugan and as shown with this and other posts further debating only leads to more irrelevant points.


*click*