Music: The R.E.D. Album vs WTT vs C4

[J-Sun Tasogare]

Everyone's probably tired of this by now, but I haven't seen anyone match all three of them up yet.

So who's best in;

Overall
Features
Flow
Lyrics
Originality

Imo I'd rank R.E.D. no#1 simply because it was consistently better than C4 and WTT.

Anyone else's opinion?

[WeezyBaby]

this is really tough................ i mean c4 and red are like a tie IMO...cant decide between wayne or game. Didnt hear WTT..dont care for it tbh

[Vatanui AKA Pride]

Overall, Watch the Throne.

In term of who was on the tracks itself, Tha Carter IV, due to three stacks. In term of best collaboration between the guests and album artists, The Throne. Artists like Bon Iver, Elly Jackson, Frank Ocean, Mr. Hudson, Swizz, etc, all worked well with Jay and Ye, adding to the quality. On the other hand, Dre and Snoop's feature on Game's RED wasn't nearly on par with any of their good works (Nothin' but a G Thang, Still D.R.E.) And Weezy's? Hah.

Flow was Jay and Kanye. Tha Carter IV can't touch Why I Love You. RED got closer, but still lost.

Read above for best lyrics.

Read above again for originality. Lil Wayne's work was as always, but subpar. The Game's new album couldn't compare at all to his previous works, such as the Doctor's Advocate.

[J-Sun Tasogare]

Originally Posted by WeezyBaby

this is really tough................ i mean c4 and red are like a tie IMO...cant decide between wayne or game. Didnt hear WTT..dont care for it tbh

Really? RED crushed C4 in almost every aspect imo, same with WTT

Originally Posted by Vatanui AKA Pride

Overall, Watch the Throne.

In term of who was on the tracks itself, Tha Carter IV, due to three stacks. In term of best collaboration between the guests and album artists, The Throne. Artists like Bon Iver, Elly Jackson, Frank Ocean, Mr. Hudson, Swizz, etc, all worked well with Jay and Ye, adding to the quality. On the other hand, Dre and Snoop's feature on Game's RED wasn't nearly on par with any of their good works (Nothin' but a G Thang, Still D.R.E.) And Weezy's? Hah.

Flow was Jay and Kanye. Tha Carter IV can't touch Why I Love You. RED got closer, but still lost.

Read above for best lyrics.

Read above again for originality. Lil Wayne's work was as always, but subpar. The Game's new album couldn't compare at all to his previous works, such as the Doctor's Advocate.

Imo Red had a better flow, if you listen to the album through and through, the songs kind of seem choppy on WTT when listened in order. For single songs WTT wins, but overall I like RED album better just for the fact that I just like how it was put together. Plus Martians vs Goblins is just awesome.

[Vatanui AKA Pride]

RED had a more consistent flow. Kanye, being Kanye, switched flows on certain songs. It worked and failed. Jay, on the meanwhile, remained top notch. Consider his flow on No Church in the Wild or Why I Love You.

However, the delivery on Watch the Throne was better.

I well agree that Watch the Throne was choppy, because it went through three revisions and certain songs didn't fit in too well others. Imo, compare a tender song like Made in America to monstrous beats like H.A.M.