![]() |
HST Chapter of the Week 17
Congratulations, HST, you've finally made up for last week's particularly slow plot advancement.
Chapter Summaries: Spoiler:
Last Week's Results: 1. Naruto 539 "A Bloody Night!"/Bleach 448 "Loading To Lie" - 7 Votes Each 3. One Piece 625 "Uninherited Will" - 5 Votes 4. 3-Way Tie - 0 Votes Voting policy: In order to vote, it's recommended that you read at least two of the chapters. If you don't want to, you don't have to read all three (even though this option is encouraged), but if you only read one chapter and vote you're just screwing up the poll. |
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
They've only slightly made up for it... Naruto beat out Bleach this week. It moved further with the temporary plot than Bleach did.
|
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
Quote:
One Piece was somewhat interesting with Otohime's death but her death as kinda plain but I get the US reference of her assassination. With Bleach there wasn't much plot advancement but character development for Orohime and Chad. |
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
A draw for me between Naruto and One Piece.
One Piece was more emotional whereas in Naruto the plot progressed significantly. Otohime's death was a reference to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s death, since they were both assassinated in broad daylight. Also they shared the same ideologies of peaceful coexistence. That really touched me in a sensible way. I found Naruto funnier, yet progressive in terms of plot. Although, this chapter was, somehow, predictable at least the plot moved. |
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
One Piece again this week.
|
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
Naruto had a little progression. But all the progression was relatively boring and predictable, which messed up the chapter, in my mind. It was the worst Naruto chapter I've read, probably ever.
One Piece however, stayed true to its roots, providing backstory, progressing the plot, and remained relatively entertaining. So, as usual, One Piece gets my vote again. I have not read the Bleach chapter. I would catch up, but even this Fullbring stuff is not interesting to me. Even though many others seem to enjoy it. |
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
You really shouldn't be voting if your not reading all 3 Maikeru. It messes up the poles.
Anyways I enjoyed all 3 chapters this week. OP and Naruto were both predictable, but the comedy with KB was funny. It was also cool for Orihime to showcase a new technique. This week I'm going with Naruto. |
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
Quote:
Whereas if you read one and vote for that you're undisputably biased and ruining the poll. |
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
I would be voting for One Piece anyways, Bleach hasn't been all that good for me since the Ulquiorra fight. If Bleach would have kept me interested earlier, maybe I'd still be reading it.
|
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
Quote:
|
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
Quote:
|
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
I'll vote when I want to and how I want to. I like One Piece more, I've liked every chapter more. The reason I vote for it every week is because I like it more every week.
|
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
Quote:
|
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
Biased is just another word for, "I like this more".
There's a reason I like it more. |
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
Quote:
And why should I have people read a series they know they don't like? It's not very likely that someone who doesn't like a series as a whole is going to pick that series' chapter over two other series that they already like. Besides that, in order to have voters keep that up, they would then have to follow the series that they don't like on a weekly basis, and I know I wouldn't do that. Basically the work outweighs the reward. And for that matter, I'm fairly certain that reading two chapters and deciding which one is better is only hurting the poll as much as it is helping it. |
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
I'm not totally biased either. I liked the Five Kage Summit more than the Luffy, Ace, Sabo Flashback. But, they weren't going on at the same time.
Now, if The World God Only Knows was in the poll, I might would vote for it over One Piece sometimes. |
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
Quote:
|
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
The only time I've ever liked Naruto or Bleach more than One Piece, is when Naruto had the Five Kaage Summit, Itachi Pursuit, Soul Society and the fights up to Ulquiorra. With those, I liked them more than the Sabo Flashback. Though, I think I liked pretty much everything else in One Piece more. One Piece is my type of story, and the writer is consistently writing chapters that I enjoy every week.
|
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
That doesn't mean I'm gonna bother policing the polls and not allowing people who don't read all three to vote, which I can't do anyways since I can't set any poll restriction and can't make any user not vote. Nor do I even have a way of checking which voters haven't read all three aside from those that posted it in the thread itself. It si simple, if someone clearly states that they don't read all 3 then don't count there vote. It takes 2 seconds to figure it out.
And why should I have people read a series they know they don't like? It's not very likely that someone who doesn't like a series as a whole is going to pick that series' chapter over two other series that they already like. Besides that, in order to have voters keep that up, they would then have to follow the series that they don't like on a weekly basis, and I know I wouldn't do that. They don't have to read it if they don't want to. They just shouldn't vote then. Simple as that. |
Re: HST Chapter of the Week 17
So, I just read the new Bleach chapter. I did like it more than the Naruto chapter. But I still enjoyed One Piece more.
|
| All times are GMT -7. The time now is 03:38 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.