Naruto Discussion Forum

Naruto Discussion Forum (http://forum.naruto.viz.com/index.php)
-   Multiverse (http://forum.naruto.viz.com/forumdisplay.php?f=130)
-   -   Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts (http://forum.naruto.viz.com/showthread.php?t=113565)

NBT 04-06-2012 11:00 AM

Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
So the other thread can get back on topic.

Devils Lawyer 04-06-2012 11:18 AM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
So basically a draw. Tailed beasts can withstand attacks capable of wiping out or changing landscapes. Never been harmed by an attack city + or below. Even then no real injuries from such attacks. The only attack to do so was a blade. Which means absolutely nothing considering said beast let itself be cut.

Mr Popo faster than kid goku....Oh wait thats it. The only feats he has besides a magic carpet.

Uchiha Sora 04-06-2012 12:50 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
Well wouldnt Popo eventually get tired?

Frost ninja 04-06-2012 01:09 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
Doubtful since he doesn't necessarily have to move all that fast to avoid the Bijuu.

Plus theres really nothing they can do to Popo that he can't simply eat or tank.

And I've never seen a Bijuu regenerate its head back... Ever.

Devils Lawyer 04-06-2012 01:17 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
So we go back to the since when does Popo have power or durability on that level discussion.

Frost ninja 04-06-2012 05:02 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
Speed is power, and he has more than enough.

Devils Lawyer 04-06-2012 06:34 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
Yeah if said speed was in a verse such as marvel then I would totally agree. But alas if every series used said principles characters ranging from someone as low as Kakashi and as fast as Goku would leave destruction in their wake. But since they don't charge that up to the game otherwise prove that it does.

Frost ninja 04-06-2012 08:17 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
Though I'd agree the principals aren't necessarily vivid in the stories, with Lee his movement on the ground tore up the entire arent just about. It just so happens most of the fights in both series involve air-based combat or non-terrain fights.

Plus, barring effects of speed, everything else in physics seems to hold true including the basic principals of gravity, inertia, and whatnot. So yes, I'd be safe to say someone who is near massively hypersonic can put a lot of power into a punch moving at said speeds upon someone like a Bijuu.

Devils Lawyer 04-06-2012 08:50 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
One you are using Naruto as an example. A manga that is younger and definetely more grounded in realism than db. Two even with what you are saying no gurantees he can generate the destruction you are suggesting. Third point what you are suggesting would essentially turn a many of a character in manga into monsters.

For example Hayato Furinji from HSDK moved so fast he couldn't be captured at 1/1000 of a sec on a high speed camera. It was a blur. Now combined that fact he can flip tamks casually. Now if you use the principles of physics with that he can essentially rape hst, db part 1, YuYu hakusho, and a great many of shounen. Now does that sound realistic? Depends if you read the series.

Vashe 04-06-2012 08:52 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
The only difference in actual physics that we can assume are those that has been shown or explained. Everything else we assume to be the same as our world otherwise all the vs debates would be invalidated for the simple reason of each verse having no valid science to draw evidence from.

If mr. Popo has speed that can amplify his offense then that should be taken into account when using him in a debate.
F = ma (Force is equal to mass multiplied with acceleration)
if someone where to say that the above given equation is not applicable to naruto then most of naruto calcs are invalidated hence making naruto characters unquantifiable and therefore making them unqualified to be used in a vs debate.

Frost ninja 04-06-2012 08:57 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
HSDK means...?

Also yes, most of them are. People, normal people, get torn into peices, possibly many... when hit by things going at sonic/supersonic speeds.

Now if he can beat whoever, depends on some things. However, 1/1000 sec high speed is... eh. Thats not too fast. But yes, if someone is going that fast and hits someone who is unable to react, it'll do some damage (depending on their Durability)

Of course, my popo ideals are before powerscaling. Afterwards, lookin at how Yamcha ended out at like SSJ1 or 2 by the end of it Popo would be...

Team four star level in power.

ILIKEPIE 04-06-2012 09:02 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
History's strongest Disciple Kenichi

Hayato is shown to have crazy power in that series compared to most of the other characters in that manga

Frost ninja 04-06-2012 09:03 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
I never read that one.

Devils Lawyer 04-06-2012 09:11 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
How about no. Going deeper and actually using physics to improve or disapprove a characters ability would essentially would invalidate almost all fictional battle series calcs. Which is already flawed system. Not only that each fictional verse is a different realm entirely. The basics are similiar but it doesn't mean that a manga artist will use all of them.

Even if you use that arguement your arguement still doesn't give Popo enough power. Last known calc around the time of arrival of popo was Tao's which was mach 7-14. Popo is faster but definetely unquanitfiable. So he is stuck at hypersonic+. So are you saying he is capable of causing power on the scale of city+ at minimum on that level? You still haven't backed up the claim at all. Not even with a simple calc. Popo is only being wanked the longer this goes on the more apparent it becomes.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Frost ninja (Post 5982398)
HSDK means...?

Also yes, most of them are. People, normal people, get torn into peices, possibly many... when hit by things going at sonic/supersonic speeds.

Now if he can beat whoever, depends on some things. However, 1/1000 sec high speed is... eh. Thats not too fast. But yes, if someone is going that fast and hits someone who is unable to react, it'll do some damage (depending on their Durability)

Of course, my popo ideals are before powerscaling. Afterwards, lookin at how Yamcha ended out at like SSJ1 or 2 by the end of it Popo would be...

Team four star level in power.

I mean it's faster than the majority of the Kid Goku saga and definetely hst in general. It has to be over mach 30 atleast. Mind you he was still a blur. Meaning he is faster still. He ran to multiple continents and searched them from to japan.

Yamcha actually tried to improve. Also he was still more a genius in combat than popo. Considering the level he got to. Popo actually didn't do anything but follow Kami. Nothing suggest he changed from Kid Goku days.

ILIKEPIE 04-06-2012 09:43 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
running on water is something that looks cool

Frost ninja 04-06-2012 09:44 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
Meh. Popo fought Goten and trunks, tanked a SSJ2 kick from one of them and it didn't do anything. Sooooo eh.

1/1000 of a sec isn't mach 30. At least not to my knowledge.
And popo is an immortal genie and whatnot, I don't see Bijuu's tanking anything.

Got feats of Bijuu tank?
Because a team of Kakuzu and Hidan were enough to kill one, and I know they aren't on par with Popo.

Devils Lawyer 04-06-2012 10:55 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Frost ninja (Post 5982516)
Meh. Popo fought Goten and trunks, tanked a SSJ2 kick from one of them and it didn't do anything. Sooooo eh.

Wasnt that anime only?

Quote:

1/1000 of a sec isn't mach 30. At least not to my knowledge.
And popo is an immortal genie and whatnot, I don't see Bijuu's tanking anything.
He is faster than that he casually moved that fast without really trying. He was playing around and the camera still couldn't catch his movements 1/1000 of a sec. Just swinging his leg he shattered sound barrier.

Quote:

Got feats of Bijuu tank?
Because a team of Kakuzu and Hidan were enough to kill one, and I know they aren't on par with Popo.
Kurama slapped a few blasts capable of vaporizing mountains. Just touching the energy is a feat. Not all bijuu are created equal obviously. But lets do bring up the fact that the host got knocked out by Kakuza and Hidan. Not all jinchuruki is created equally. The Hachibi tanked his own blast. Just the 9 tails and hachibi is suffucient in the durability point.

Frost ninja 04-06-2012 11:18 PM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
Meh, okay.

A draw then.

Vashe 04-07-2012 03:06 AM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Devils Lawyer (Post 5982433)
How about no. Going deeper and actually using physics to improve or disapprove a characters ability would essentially would invalidate almost all fictional battle series calcs. Which is already flawed system. Not only that each fictional verse is a different realm entirely. The basics are similiar but it doesn't mean that a manga artist will use all of them.

Even if you use that arguement your arguement still doesn't give Popo enough power. Last known calc around the time of arrival of popo was Tao's which was mach 7-14. Popo is faster but definetely unquanitfiable. So he is stuck at hypersonic+. So are you saying he is capable of causing power on the scale of city+ at minimum on that level? You still haven't backed up the claim at all. Not even with a simple calc. Popo is only being wanked the longer this goes on the more apparent it becomes.

He is capable of firing of punches on that low-end, something that bijuus are unable to react to.... and it has been explicitly stated by AT (the author himself) that mr. popo is on a power level comparable to raditz... a character who was blitzing early saiyan saga goku and piccolo who is way more powerful than taopaipai himself... and like i said, its highly illogical that mr. popo stayed on the same power level through the entire series...

Quote:

I mean it's faster than the majority of the Kid Goku saga and definetely hst in general. It has to be over mach 30 atleast. Mind you he was still a blur. Meaning he is faster still. He ran to multiple continents and searched them from to japan.
1/1000 of a second is only a timeframe... if you are referring to hayato's kicks then assuming he can kick for 2 meters (1 meter for motioning his legs forward and 1 meter taking it back)... we get:

1/1000 = .001 sec = time
2m = distance
and since speed is distance over time...
2m /.001
2000m/sec which is barely low hypersonic... so your claim is the wanked claim... you can try to debunk the calc... XD but your claim is absolutely untrue about hayato being mach 30... check your claims first before posting dude...

Quote:

Yamcha actually tried to improve. Also he was still more a genius in combat than popo. Considering the level he got to. Popo actually didn't do anything but follow Kami. Nothing suggest he changed from Kid Goku days.
even if we grant that mr. popo has stayed on the power level of raditz the entire series, it is still enough to beat HST characters... so your argument doesn't really help your case dude... :D

Devils Lawyer 04-07-2012 10:12 AM

Re: Mr.Popo vs. Tailed Beasts
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Vashe (Post 5982758)
He is capable of firing of punches on that low-end, something that bijuus are unable to react to.... and it has been explicitly stated by AT (the author himself) that mr. popo is on a power level comparable to raditz... a character who was blitzing early saiyan saga goku and piccolo who is way more powerful than taopaipai himself... and like i said, its highly illogical that mr. popo stayed on the same power level through the entire series...

Kami, Roshi, the cat, Yajarobi, all have something in common. All characters who stop growing at a certain point. Your logic is flawed. Mr popo is the servant to one of them. But sure I will bite give some canon from the manga not some artist answering to fanboys I will beleive he could be on Raditz level. :lol:


Quote:


1/1000 of a second is only a timeframe... if you are referring to hayato's kicks then assuming he can kick for 2 meters (1 meter for motioning his legs forward and 1 meter taking it back)... we get:

1/1000 = .001 sec = time
2m = distance
and since speed is distance over time...
2m /.001
2000m/sec which is barely low hypersonic... so your claim is the wanked claim... you can try to debunk the calc... XD but your claim is absolutely untrue about hayato being mach 30... check your claims first before posting dude...

How about no. The mach 30 wasn't my calc. The obd made it. Calcs in general are a joke to me. I only throw them back into individuals such as yourself face who uses them. But anyways the calc was backed up by the fact he runs on water and even at 1/1000 on camera his movements can't be seen. If you actually read what I said to frost you would note I said he was playing around and casually shattered the sound barrier on camera.

Quote:

even if we grant that mr. popo has stayed on the power level of raditz the entire series, it is still enough to beat HST characters... so your argument doesn't really help your case dude... :D
But he is not. He is weaker.:lol:


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 08:21 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.