One Piece: Arc Villain Fights

[NagatoGod_of_Pain]

I wanted to see who would be considered the strongest villain of the 3 major arcs before Marineford. I couldn't find any related threads in the search section.

Crocodile vs. Enel

Crocodile vs. Rob Lucci

Enel vs. Rob Lucci

Details applies to all fights.

Location: Open field

Distance: 30m

Characters do know of each others abilities (ex: Enel has mantra, Crocodile's right hand, Lucci's various techniques), but don't know of each others weaknesses. (ex: Required to be wet to hit Crocodile, insulators affect Enel)

[Nyruss]

Enel's lightning turns Croc into glass. Enel stomps.

There is nothing Lucci could ever possibly do to harm Crocodile in any way.
There is nothing Lucci could ever possibly do to harm Enel in any way.

[Lone Wolf]

Enel rapes, zap away and El Thor, GG.

[Kakashi Hatake_Yamato]

basically enel zaps everyone...match finished

[zetsu2141]

Enel easily stomps crocodile
Unless lucci accidently gets his body wet he can't hurt crocodile at all
Theres nothing at all lucci can do to hurt enel

[Miles Edgeworth]

Enel could probably blitz Crocodile in logia form and easily zap him, I don't see how Crocodile can kill him.

Lucci is even easier since he lacks logia and really can't hurt Enel.

Lucci gets taken out by Ground Death or Sables, Croc could poison him too.

[NagatoGod_of_Pain]

I expected this. I've read at various other sites that say outrageous claims such as "Lucci beats Crocodile because he was an even match for Gear 2nd/3rd Luffy while Crocodile lost to an early Luffy etc."

Would Enel not knowing about Crocodile's right hand make it anymore even? Even with having his logia mastered to the point of turning into sand as a reflex, Enel turning Crocodile into glass is reasonable. Though with Enel being overconfident, I would imagine Enel letting Crocodile attack him hoping to see him fail.

[Nyruss]

Personality flaws such as arrogance do not factor in to Battleground debates, Enel will use whatever means necessary to win from the start of the fight.

Crocodile's Logia intangibility is not his only saving grace. Even if Lucci somehow managed to bypass that, Crocodile took an attack from Jozu without dying instantly. Or even suffering any significant wounds.

I assure you that Jozu > Lucci in every conceivable way.

[NagatoGod_of_Pain]

I know about the personality rule, but I was just thinking in character for them/if they ever met in the story. My bad for making it seem like I was talking about the BG fight.

I agree that Lucci can't significantly hurt Crocodile either. If Crocodile can tank a diamond punch to the face, Lucci would have a hard time even if he did had haki.

Yes, Jozu has to be at least around Lucci in terms of power. He has shown shown pretty darn good feats though so the likeliness of being stronger than Lucci is high.

[Nyruss]

Stronger than Lucci. Understatement of the century. That iceberg Jozu casually tossed across Marineford was estimate to weight around a million tons.

If Lucci is anywhere near Jozu in power I'm Mary Queen of Scots.

[Akatsuki X]

Enel wins both of his fights,
Croc beats Rob.

Rob has nothing on either of them, he dosen't even have Logia intangibility.

Enel could spam lightning and eventually bring down Croc.