Who is tobi?

[Madara Tobi]

As you know Tobi has been declared "Madara Uchiha" for a long time now, but I think otherwise, not only is it physically impossible for anyone to live that long but also not much evidence has been shown.

I want to know who you guys think Tobi really is so please post it here, anyone, any guesses, and please try to give an explanation:D

[AkiraNeko]

Well, it is possible, because it's Naruto. We're not talking the real world here. Anything could happen. Also, many other threads have been made like this, so there is no need to make another.

Sorry to burst your bubble...><

[zerosameri]

Tobi is Madara Uchiha nothing more to it.

[Hidden Ninja45]

There is a lot of debate about who Tobi is. I think he is Madara Uchiha.

[Madara Tobi]

Yes it is Naruto, like it was mentioned because it is Naruto anything can happen, as far as we all know it has never been set in stone that Tobi is Madara, we wil confirm that as soon as he removes his mask until then I refuse to believe what most others think about Tobi being Madara. In my opinion I think is a character that has yet to be revealed in the manga series.

[madara']

There's a theory that Obito's was found by somebody and they somehow revived him. Now he calls himself Madara Uchiha or Tobi.
(Hint):You'll know he's Obito because his left eye is covered with straps because it was smushed.

[HiddenRoar]

"As you know Tobi has been declared "Madara Uchiha" for a long time now, but I think otherwise, not only is it physically impossible for anyone to live that long but also not much evidence has been shown."

Kakuzu

"I refuse to believe what most others think about Tobi being Madara."

Let's ignore the fact that Kisame, Itachi, the 4th, and Jiraiya stated otherwise.
Madara wanted revenge on Konoha.
Madara wanted revenge on the Uchiha.
Madara is one of the four people known to control a TB.
The Kyuubi referred to Sasuke's eyes as being as sinister as Madara's (Didn't mention anyone else)
Madara can't die (According to Itachi)
The timeline would only fit Madara (Obito is too young, Shisui also [Yes... there are people who believe Tobi is really Shisui])
Tobi stated that Kisame was closest to him (Which would make sense since he was a Mizukage and would have been in charge of the SSotM)
Etc. Cause I'm busy.

For those holding on to your Tobi=Obito, you can keep believing in your tobitobi/opposite eye but that would be really sad...

[Madara Tobi]

"Let's ignore the fact that Kisame, Itachi, the 4th, and Jiraiya stated otherwise.
Madara wanted revenge on Konoha.
Madara wanted revenge on the Uchiha.
Madara is one of the four people known to control a TB.
The Kyuubi referred to Sasuke's eyes as being as sinister as Madara's (Didn't mention anyone else)
Madara can't die (According to Itachi)
The timeline would only fit Madara (Obito is too young, Shisui also [Yes... there are people who believe Tobi is really Shisui])
Tobi stated that Kisame was closest to him (Which would make sense since he was a Mizukage and would have been in charge of the SSotM)
Etc. Cause I'm busy.

For those holding on to your Tobi=Obito, you can keep believing in your tobitobi/opposite eye but that would be really sad... "

I'm sorry you disagree but I was just stating my opinion, but you are probably right because so many peole have said that he is Madara, if it turned out to be false many people will be upset to say the least..........

[X__Sasuke__X]

You know... this conversation would go great in the Town Bookstore... :P More people would discuss this I bet.