VGA Game of the Year Revote

[RINNEMAN1]

Who should it have been.

Actual winner: The Elder Scrolls: Skyrim

[Sharingan19]

Batman: Arkham City. That game was awesome, great story, great gameplay and the graphics are amazing.
My Game Of The Year easily.

[Taker369]

Skyward sword is game of the year Arkham city was good but it just seems to be lacking something on the other hand Skyward sword is hands down the winner its underrated and looked down upon because its for the wii when its a hell of alot better then alot of other games that are glitchy and broken Skyrim plus the soundtrack is amazing and there's so much to be done in the game and the controls work great and its not the same old zelda game over and over like haters say

[deidara#1]

No suprise here, a Nintendo game is winning on this forum.

Obviously it's Skyrim.

[Taker369]

skyrim is glitchy as hell it dont deserve game of the year

[Vivi]

skyrim is glitchy as hell it dont deserve game of the year

Thats your reasoning?

Every game has flaws in some way.

Skyrim is glitchy big deal.Just mean the rest is so good that it trumps over the glitches.
There is no perfect game.

Battlefield 3 on PC shuts down when taking a certain route in a level.Does that mean its bad?

[Taker369]

wouldn't know dont play shooters and i played skyrim its ok but its over hyped

[RINNEMAN1]

I think Arkham City for Open World, but my vote is not too valid since I don't have it.

[sagemaster777]

Would be between arkham city or skyward sword for me.

[Nābris]

Actual winner: The Elder Scrolls: Skyrim
And that's where it should stand. `;)

[Vocaloid]

I'm biased towards Skyward Sword, but what little of Portal 2 I played was great.

[assassin]

Zelda.

[tanoth]

I have yet to play these mentioned games so that I may determine which one defines the game of the year for me.

Edit: I've only managed to play through Skyrim and Skyward Sword so far.

[Space Cowboy Sasori]

Skyrim won, and was supposed to win.

[Taker369]

because spike said so ?

[Nābris]

Nah, because it actually deserved it. :geek:

[Taker369]

the game was all hype and fully of glitches how is that a game of the year ?

[J-Sun Tasogare]

Skyrim won because it's the most well-done game of the year. If you actually play-through it, it's great easily has the best art of all the games up there, and is the best game Bethesda has put out. Which is saying a lot when they've made games like Oblivion and Fallout 3.

The worst glitch I've ever had was it freezing at one point, and a quest being bugged. But it's much better than Fallout 3 and it auto saves like 5 times so you won't lose progress.

And of course a game as large as Skyrim is going to have bugs, you can put a hundred hours into the game and not even be close to done with it. None of the others can do that, besides maybe Batman, but you should be done with it by then

the game was all hype and fully of glitches how is that a game of the year ?
It actually wasn't all hype, just because you obviously are biased in Zelda's favor doesn't mean everyone else is. It's not full of glitches, yes it has some but they're not major, some are even fun.

It won game of the year because it has the biggest amount of content, best art work of any Bethesda game, best combat sequence of any Bethesda game, and it's dungeons are just awesome. If you haven't put hours into the game you can't talk about it.

Plus Skyrim sold 3.5 million copies in two days, while Zelda only sold half a million in 8 days.

[Taker369]

like i care what u think about zelda i played skyrim and didn't care for it therefore i voted for zelda its a better game to me and whoopy doo Skyrim sold more then zelda dont mean anything to me i like Zelda more and to be honest i didn't care for oblivion either :/

[J-Sun Tasogare]

like i care what u think about zelda i played skyrim and didn't care for it therefore i voted for zelda its a better game to me and whoopy doo Skyrim sold more then zelda dont mean anything to me i like Zelda more and to be honest i didn't care for oblivion either :/

Exactly to YOU it is. But to the millions of other people who voted for Skyrim, it's better therefore you can't try to push that it isn't a good game. I never once said Zelda wasn't a good game, it is and that's why it got the legend award. But like I said you're obviously biased to Zelda in the first place.

[Nābris]

the game was all hype and fully of glitches how is that a game of the year ?
One could argue that Skyward Sword had just as much hype. It depends on where you look, who you are talking too, and etcetera. In my opinion, both games got enough hype that they ultimately deserved.

As with the glitches, here are some of my inputs and observations: I've never experienced a single one that was game breaking or annoying enough to make me quit the game. Most of them could easily be fixed by reloading/leaving the room, and heck some of them are hilarious (Giant glitch and the Farkas glitches). Despite the glitches, I'm still playing, and I am still loving it. That's how good of a game it is. :lol:

I should point out that I am in no way saying that Skyward sword is a bad game; it was wonderful. I enjoyed it. However, I can't place it before Skyrim. Sorry.

[Demise]

I'm with Skyrim.

A glitch in a Bethesda game is like a signature. :lol:

[SasukeDude96]

Skyward Sword all the dang way.

[Maikeru D. Shinigami]

I haven't actually played Skyrim. What exactly sets it apart from other games of the same genre? What part of the game is unique or innovative? I'm curious, because I've played games that look similar to the play style of Skyrim, and they haven't left a huge enough lasting impression on me for me to call them masterpieces.

[J-Sun Tasogare]

I haven't actually played Skyrim. What exactly sets it apart from other games of the same genre? What part of the game is unique or innovative? I'm curious, because I've played games that look similar to the play style of Skyrim, and they haven't left a huge enough lasting impression on me for me to call them masterpieces.

The depthness they put in the game. When you play the game you don't feel like you're playing the game, you feel like you're inside this massive world. Unlike other RPG's the world doesn't revolve around you, the entire environment and storyline feels like it's been around since before you began playing it, and will be there long after you leave. The sheer amount of freedom you have in the world is the best I've seen, you can literally do nearly anything you can think of, and everything has a purpose. Even eating butterfly wings has a purpose. No other RPG I've played does that, even the other Bethesda games I've played don't do that. The lore is absolutely massive if you choose to follow it, there are tons of books you can fill your bookshelf up with that all have to do with the lore of Skyrim. The combat system is fun there are several different ways to play, you can go the basic sword and shield or use telepathy and an ice spell. The dungeons are awesome, they have puzzles and traps, and are very Indian Jones like. Ontop of that the story is engaging and the leveling system is great.

[Maikeru D. Shinigami]

The depthness they put in the game. When you play the game you don't feel like you're playing the game, you feel like you're inside this massive world. Unlike other RPG's the world doesn't revolve around you, the entire environment and storyline feels like it's been around since before you began playing it, and will be there long after you leave. The sheer amount of freedom you have in the world is the best I've seen, you can literally do nearly anything you can think of, and everything has a purpose. Even eating butterfly wings has a purpose. No other RPG I've played does that, even the other Bethesda games I've played don't do that. The lore is absolutely massive if you choose to follow it, there are tons of books you can fill your bookshelf up with that all have to do with the lore of Skyrim. The combat system is fun there are several different ways to play, you can go the basic sword and shield or use telepathy and an ice spell. The dungeons are awesome, they have puzzles and traps, and are very Indian Jones like. Ontop of that the story is engaging and the leveling system is great.

That reason is good enough for me to give a shot and try it for myself. Freedom is good and all, but what really stands out to me is the story and any unique elements of gameplay. Any thought-provoking moments or any moments that you don't just see in every game. One thing I really loved about Skyward Sword was the themes of the areas. The Ancient Cistern's sort "Water Dungeon hiding a Cursed Cavern" theme, was really beautiful. I also really love that it wasn't just a realistic art style. I find that refreshing, especially for the style it had. That world was much smaller than Skyrim obviously, but there was also a lot to do around the area. I definitely will have to play Skyrim to compare the two for myself. I did enjoy the 2008 Prince of Persia more than all of the Zelda games aside from Majora's Mask after all.

Does Skyrim have any very interesting areas? Not just like forests, caves, mountains and villages. Does it have any areas that are just very well designed, with or without traps?

[J-Sun Tasogare]

That reason is good enough for me to give a shot and try it for myself. Freedom is good and all, but what really stands out to me is the story and any unique elements of gameplay. Any thought-provoking moments or any moments that you don't just see in every game. One thing I really loved about Skyward Sword was the themes of the areas. The Ancient Cistern's sort "Water Dungeon hiding a Cursed Cavern" theme, was really beautiful. I also really love that it wasn't just a realistic art style. I find that refreshing, especially for the style it had. That world was much smaller than Skyrim obviously, but there was also a lot to do around the area. I definitely will have to play Skyrim to compare the two for myself. I did enjoy the 2008 Prince of Persia more than all of the Zelda games aside from Majora's Mask after all.

Does Skyrim have any very interesting areas? Not just like forests, caves, mountains and villages. Does it have any areas that are just very well designed, with or without traps?
Skyrim's envrionment is very huge,the environment is just great, and the designs of the monsters and such are great.

http://www.plughead.net/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/Skyrim-Solitude.jpg
http://th02.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/f/2011/324/3/d/beautiful_skyrim_night_sky_panorama_by_mallony-d4gqy4s.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v626/ROXunreal/sky1.jpg
http://www.skyrim5.com/images/skyrim-dragon-1.jpg


The Dwarven ruins are pretty awesome
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-Pz0oz1356f4/Tt9ddgrj10I/AAAAAAAABlU/u6i4_A_Uz1k/s1600/skyrim-design-dwemer.jpg
http://images.wikia.com/elderscrolls/images/d/de/Great_Lift_At_Raldbthar_Inside.jpg
One of the best puzzles in the dungeons that I've been to was when they had these revolving pillars with eagles, fish, and snakes on them. And one one pillar it was raining, on the other it was grassy, and the last one it was sunny and had a big opening in the dungeon. The animals matched the environment., it was pretty clever actually. Some are easy to figure out and some are more challenging. Traps are everywhere, tripwire, arrows, push plates, oil with fire lamps hanging from above, swinging axes. They're very common and fun.

Plus Shouts are great, being able to slow time, and summon storms is pretty cool.

[Sharingan19]

The depthness they put in the game. When you play the game you don't feel like you're playing the game, you feel like you're inside this massive world. Unlike other RPG's the world doesn't revolve around you, the entire environment and storyline feels like it's been around since before you began playing it, and will be there long after you leave. The sheer amount of freedom you have in the world is the best I've seen, you can literally do nearly anything you can think of, and everything has a purpose. Even eating butterfly wings has a purpose. No other RPG I've played does that, even the other Bethesda games I've played don't do that. The lore is absolutely massive if you choose to follow it, there are tons of books you can fill your bookshelf up with that all have to do with the lore of Skyrim. The combat system is fun there are several different ways to play, you can go the basic sword and shield or use telepathy and an ice spell. The dungeons are awesome, they have puzzles and traps, and are very Indian Jones like. Ontop of that the story is engaging and the leveling system is great.

I've just started playing Skyrim and it is amazing so far. Clearing out dungeons is pretty awesome. The graphics are not the best i've seen in a game but it doesn't matter because the environment and the world are good enough to overshadow it. It is so expansive and detailed, it does feel like you are in and part of that world.
I agree with everything J-Sun Tasogare says ^^

[Vatanui AKA Pride]

A tie between Portal 2 and Arkham City at the moment.

Skyrim may be the tiebreaker though, as I've just gotten it for Christmas. I'll play it on Christmas.

[silverclaimer musica]

Skyrim all the way.
I love the feel of the game. It feels fresh and new. Thats one of the kinds of game feel I like. Fresh and new, or nice and nostalgic.
I had the greatest feel of nostalgia when I played Halo CE anniversary. Its like it had some aspect that other Halo games were missing. Some sort of element that I haven't felt with any other game, before, or since.
Thats what really matters to me. Not graphics, not gameplay, not even story. What I love, is the feel of the game as I am playing it.
I love the frustration when Im stuck on an exceptionally difficult level. I love the joy of accomplishing something big, like beating a tough boss, or acquiring the best weapon.
I love the feel of Skyrim, just like I love the feel of the Zelda games.
But my vote, honestly has to go to Skyrim. It feels better to me. Its a bigger game, with a great feel, and a wonderful experience. Skyrim will for sure provide me with many hours of entertainment, for a long long time.

[BoxHead]

Here's what pisses me off:
Guy at school: ZOMG UR PLAYING WERLD OF WARCRAP AND SUM GAME ON WII?!?
Me: Yeah, and I'm playing Zelda Skyward Sword
Guy: WOW NINTENDURD SUX CUZ DER GRAPHICS SUX
Me: Graphic's don't make a game.
Guy: YEAH DEY DO!!!!!!!1!!11!one!1 AND WOW IS FOR FAT PEOPLE WHO LIVE IN DER MOMS BASMENTS CUZ DEY HAVE NO FRIENDS.
Me: I have lot's of friends, and I haven't finished school, retard, so I live at home, but not in the basement.
Guy: WHATEVAR SKYRIM IS TEH BEST MY NORD CULD KEEL JOOR WOW GUY
...I have to face bigots like that everytime I bring up video games